Top 9 Rarest Buffalo Nickels Ever Made

9. 1921-s regular strike

$51750

8. 1937-d 3 legs buffalo nickel

$99875

7. 1935 doubled die reverse

$104650

6. 1919-s buffalo nickel

$109250

5. 1917-s buffalo nickel

$138000

4. 1913-d buffalo nickel

$143750

3. 1916-6 doubled die variety

$281750

2. 1926-s buffalo nickel

$322000

1. 1918-7-d buffalo nickel

$350750